After a few weeks of controversy the discourse about which ideological faction “won” the midterms seems to be settling in to a consensus. Insofar as the metrics tell us anything, they say at the very worst that centrists outperformed the left by a vanishingly tiny margin. That they tell us much at all is not actually that clear, as Matt Bruenig points out — but here, I’m going to insist that insofar as they do, they don’t tell quite the story that centrist think they tell.
To appreciate it, just consider this graph of factional wins-over-replacements:



